Nuclear Density
Two nuclei have mass numbers 27 and 125 respectively, and both obey the standard nuclear radius relation. What is the ratio of the nuclear mass density of the lighter nucleus to that of the heavier nucleus?
Select the correct option:
Solution
1 : 1
Nuclear density is the nuclear mass divided by the nuclear volume. The mass is proportional to A (each nucleon contributing roughly the same mass), while the volume is 34πR3=34πR03A because R=R0A1/3 makes R3∝A. Therefore density ρ=volumemass∝AA=constant, completely independent of the mass number. Both nuclei thus have identical density, giving the ratio 1:1. The value 27:125 wrongly assumes density scales with mass number directly. The value 3:5 uses the radius ratio A1/3 and ignores that both mass and volume scale together. The value 125:27 inverts an already incorrect mass-number reasoning. This constancy is strong evidence that the nuclear force saturates: each nucleon interacts only with its immediate neighbours rather than with every other nucleon, keeping the packing uniform throughout the nuclear volume. This is the celebrated NCERT result that all nuclei share a near-constant density of about 2.3×1017 kg/m³. A plausibility check confirms that because R3 and mass both grow linearly with A, their ratio cancels exactly, leaving density the same for every nucleus.
🔒 Solution Hidden from View
Submit your answer to unlock the detailed step-by-step solution.
About This Question
- Subject
- physics
- Chapter
- atoms and nuclei
- Topic
- nuclear density
- Difficulty
- Medium
- Year
- 2025
Solution
Correct Answer:
1 : 1
Nuclear density is the nuclear mass divided by the nuclear volume. The mass is proportional to A (each nucleon contributing roughly the same mass), while the volume is 34πR3=34πR03A because R=R0A1/3 makes R3∝A. Therefore density ρ=volumemass∝AA=constant, completely independent of the mass number. Both nuclei thus have identical density, giving the ratio 1:1. The value 27:125 wrongly assumes density scales with mass number directly. The value 3:5 uses the radius ratio A1/3 and ignores that both mass and volume scale together. The value 125:27 inverts an already incorrect mass-number reasoning. This constancy is strong evidence that the nuclear force saturates: each nucleon interacts only with its immediate neighbours rather than with every other nucleon, keeping the packing uniform throughout the nuclear volume. This is the celebrated NCERT result that all nuclei share a near-constant density of about 2.3×1017 kg/m³. A plausibility check confirms that because R3 and mass both grow linearly with A, their ratio cancels exactly, leaving density the same for every nucleus.
This medium difficulty physics question is from the chapter atoms and nuclei, covering the topic of nuclear density. It appeared in the 2025 exam.
Looking for more practice? Explore all physics questions or browse atoms and nuclei questions on RankGuru.