Second Law Of Thermodynamics
An inventor claims a machine that, working in a cycle, absorbs heat from a single reservoir and converts all of it entirely into mechanical work with nothing else changing. Why is this impossible?
Select the correct option:
🔒 Solution Hidden from View
Submit your answer to unlock the detailed step-by-step solution.
More thermodynamics Practice Questions
A student claims to have built an engine that takes heat from a single reservoir and converts all of...
A student claims to have built an engine that takes heat from a single reservoir and converts all of...
For a diatomic ideal gas the molar specific heat at constant volume is 5R/2, so what is the value of...
For a diatomic ideal gas the molar specific heat at constant volume is 5R/2, so what is the value of...
A gas is taken around a complete thermodynamic cycle and returns to its original state after several...
A gas is taken around a complete thermodynamic cycle and returns to its original state after several...
Two moles of an ideal gas expand isothermally at 300 K from a volume V to a volume 2V in a slow reve...
Two moles of an ideal gas expand isothermally at 300 K from a volume V to a volume 2V in a slow reve...
A balloon suddenly bursts and the compressed gas inside rushes out into the open atmosphere very rap...
A balloon suddenly bursts and the compressed gas inside rushes out into the open atmosphere very rap...
When 2 moles of a monatomic ideal gas are heated at constant pressure causing a temperature rise of ...
When 2 moles of a monatomic ideal gas are heated at constant pressure causing a temperature rise of ...
On a pressure-volume diagram an isothermal curve and an adiabatic curve pass through the same point ...
On a pressure-volume diagram an isothermal curve and an adiabatic curve pass through the same point ...
A heat pump uses 200 J of work to deliver a total of 800 J of heat into a warm room during each oper...
A heat pump uses 200 J of work to deliver a total of 800 J of heat into a warm room during each oper...
Two identical samples of the same ideal gas are kept at the same temperature but stored at very diff...
Two identical samples of the same ideal gas are kept at the same temperature but stored at very diff...
One mole of an ideal gas is compressed isothermally at temperature 300 K, so what happens to its int...
One mole of an ideal gas is compressed isothermally at temperature 300 K, so what happens to its int...
Heat of 400 J is supplied to a gas sealed inside a rigid steel container whose volume cannot change,...
Heat of 400 J is supplied to a gas sealed inside a rigid steel container whose volume cannot change,...
An ideal gas expands at a constant pressure of 2 × 10^5 Pa, increasing its volume from 0.01 m^3 to 0...
An ideal gas expands at a constant pressure of 2 × 10^5 Pa, increasing its volume from 0.01 m^3 to 0...
About This Question
- Subject
- physics
- Chapter
- thermodynamics
- Topic
- second law of thermodynamics
- Difficulty
- Medium
- Year
- 2025
Solution
Correct Answer:
It violates the Kelvin-Planck statement of the Second Law
The Kelvin-Planck statement of the Second Law declares that no process is possible whose sole result is the complete conversion of heat from a single reservoir into work. A real cyclic engine must always reject some heat to a colder reservoir, so 100 percent conversion in a cycle is forbidden. The proposed machine does not violate the First Law, because energy could still be conserved if heat in equalled work out; conservation alone does not rule it out, which is precisely why a second principle is needed. The Zeroth Law concerns thermal equilibrium and temperature definition, irrelevant here. The absolute-zero reservoir idea confuses this with the requirement for a Carnot engine to reach unit efficiency. The deeper reason is that converting disordered thermal energy fully into ordered work would decrease total entropy, which the Second Law prohibits. Such a hypothetical device is called a perpetual motion machine of the second kind, and its impossibility is logically equivalent to the Clausius statement forbidding spontaneous heat flow from cold to hot. As a consistency check, every working engine ever built rejects waste heat to the environment, empirically confirming that a single-reservoir perfect converter cannot exist no matter how cleverly it is designed.
This medium difficulty physics question is from the chapter thermodynamics, covering the topic of second law of thermodynamics. It appeared in the 2025 exam.
Looking for more practice? Explore all physics questions or browse thermodynamics questions on RankGuru.