Slope Of Adiabatic Versus Isothermal Curve
On a pressure-volume diagram an isothermal curve and an adiabatic curve pass through the same point for an ideal gas, so how do their slopes compare at that common point?
Select the correct option:
Solution
The adiabatic curve is steeper than the isothermal curve
Building on the process equations in NCERT Class 11, Chapter 12 (Thermodynamics), the slope of each curve is found by differentiating its governing relation. For an isothermal process an ideal gas obeys PV=constant, so differentiating gives the slope (dVdP)iso=−VP. For an adiabatic process the gas obeys PVγ=constant, which on differentiation gives (dVdP)adi=−γVP. At the common point the values of P and V are identical for both curves, so the ratio of the two slopes is exactly γ, the ratio of specific heats, which is always greater than 1 for any gas. Therefore the adiabatic slope has the larger magnitude and the adiabatic curve is the steeper of the two. The option saying the isothermal is steeper is wrong because that would require γ<1, which never holds. The option of equal slopes is wrong because it would need γ=1, impossible for any real gas. The option claiming a positive adiabatic slope is wrong because both slopes are negative; pressure falls as volume rises in both processes. A consistency check seals it: since γ>1 for all gases, ∣−γP/V∣>∣−P/V∣ always, so the adiabatic curve must drop more sharply at the shared point.
🔒 Solution Hidden from View
Submit your answer to unlock the detailed step-by-step solution.
About This Question
- Subject
- physics
- Chapter
- thermodynamics
- Topic
- slope of adiabatic versus isothermal curve
- Difficulty
- Hard
- Year
- 2025
Solution
Correct Answer:
The adiabatic curve is steeper than the isothermal curve
Building on the process equations in NCERT Class 11, Chapter 12 (Thermodynamics), the slope of each curve is found by differentiating its governing relation. For an isothermal process an ideal gas obeys PV=constant, so differentiating gives the slope (dVdP)iso=−VP. For an adiabatic process the gas obeys PVγ=constant, which on differentiation gives (dVdP)adi=−γVP. At the common point the values of P and V are identical for both curves, so the ratio of the two slopes is exactly γ, the ratio of specific heats, which is always greater than 1 for any gas. Therefore the adiabatic slope has the larger magnitude and the adiabatic curve is the steeper of the two. The option saying the isothermal is steeper is wrong because that would require γ<1, which never holds. The option of equal slopes is wrong because it would need γ=1, impossible for any real gas. The option claiming a positive adiabatic slope is wrong because both slopes are negative; pressure falls as volume rises in both processes. A consistency check seals it: since γ>1 for all gases, ∣−γP/V∣>∣−P/V∣ always, so the adiabatic curve must drop more sharply at the shared point.
This hard difficulty physics question is from the chapter thermodynamics, covering the topic of slope of adiabatic versus isothermal curve. It appeared in the 2025 exam.
Looking for more practice? Explore all physics questions or browse thermodynamics questions on RankGuru.