Isothermal Versus Adiabatic Curves
On a single pressure-volume diagram an isothermal curve and an adiabatic curve for the same ideal gas pass through one common point. Which statement correctly compares their slopes at that intersection?
Select the correct option:
Solution
The adiabatic curve is steeper by a factor of γ
Differentiating the isothermal condition PV=constant gives PdV+VdP=0, so the isothermal slope is (dVdP)T=−VP. Differentiating the adiabatic condition PVγ=constant gives γPVγ−1dV+VγdP=0, so the adiabatic slope is (dVdP)adia=−γVP. At the shared point P and V are identical, so the adiabatic slope is exactly γ times the isothermal slope in magnitude. Since γ>1 for any real gas, the adiabatic curve falls more steeply. The option that the isothermal is steeper reverses the ratio. The option of identical slopes ignores the factor γ entirely. The option that the adiabatic is flatter by γ contradicts γ>1. Physically, during adiabatic expansion the gas also cools, so its pressure drops faster than in the isothermal case where temperature is held fixed. This steeper slope has a practical consequence: in the sound-propagation context, Newton's isothermal assumption underestimated the speed of sound until Laplace corrected it using the adiabatic relation, restoring agreement with measurement. A check confirms that with γ=1.4 the adiabatic line is 1.4 times as steep at the crossing point, consistent with experiment.
🔒 Solution Hidden from View
Submit your answer to unlock the detailed step-by-step solution.
About This Question
- Subject
- physics
- Chapter
- thermodynamics
- Topic
- isothermal versus adiabatic curves
- Difficulty
- Hard
- Year
- 2025
Solution
Correct Answer:
The adiabatic curve is steeper by a factor of γ
Differentiating the isothermal condition PV=constant gives PdV+VdP=0, so the isothermal slope is (dVdP)T=−VP. Differentiating the adiabatic condition PVγ=constant gives γPVγ−1dV+VγdP=0, so the adiabatic slope is (dVdP)adia=−γVP. At the shared point P and V are identical, so the adiabatic slope is exactly γ times the isothermal slope in magnitude. Since γ>1 for any real gas, the adiabatic curve falls more steeply. The option that the isothermal is steeper reverses the ratio. The option of identical slopes ignores the factor γ entirely. The option that the adiabatic is flatter by γ contradicts γ>1. Physically, during adiabatic expansion the gas also cools, so its pressure drops faster than in the isothermal case where temperature is held fixed. This steeper slope has a practical consequence: in the sound-propagation context, Newton's isothermal assumption underestimated the speed of sound until Laplace corrected it using the adiabatic relation, restoring agreement with measurement. A check confirms that with γ=1.4 the adiabatic line is 1.4 times as steep at the crossing point, consistent with experiment.
This hard difficulty physics question is from the chapter thermodynamics, covering the topic of isothermal versus adiabatic curves. It appeared in the 2025 exam.
Looking for more practice? Explore all physics questions or browse thermodynamics questions on RankGuru.