Escape Velocity And Planetary Density
Two rocky planets A and B are made of material of exactly the same uniform density, but planet B has a radius twice that of planet A. What is the ratio of the escape velocity from planet A to the escape velocity from planet B?
Select the correct option:
Solution
1 : 2
Escape velocity is ve=R2GM, but for planets of identical density the mass must be written in terms of radius using M=34πR3ρ. Substituting gives ve=R2G⋅34πR3ρ=38πGρR, showing that for fixed density the escape velocity is directly proportional to the radius. Therefore ve,Bve,A=RBRA=2RR=21, giving the ratio 1 : 2. The option 1 : 4 wrongly uses the square of the radius ratio. The option 1 : √2 incorrectly takes a square root, ignoring that mass grows as the cube of radius. The option 1 : 8 mistakenly applies the full cube. This extends the NCERT escape-velocity result to bodies of equal density. The relation ve=38πGρR is a useful diagnostic because it cleanly separates the two ways a planet can have a high escape velocity: by being made of denser material, or by being physically larger. For planet B, the radius doubles and the mass grows eightfold as R3, yet because escape velocity depends on the mass-to-radius combination M/R, the net scaling reduces to simple proportionality with radius. A plausibility check confirms that the larger planet, packing eight times the mass into twice the radius, demands a higher escape speed, so planet A's escape velocity being half that of B is consistent.
🔒 Solution Hidden from View
Submit your answer to unlock the detailed step-by-step solution.
About This Question
- Subject
- physics
- Chapter
- gravitation
- Topic
- escape velocity and planetary density
- Difficulty
- Hard
- Year
- 2025
Solution
Correct Answer:
1 : 2
Escape velocity is ve=R2GM, but for planets of identical density the mass must be written in terms of radius using M=34πR3ρ. Substituting gives ve=R2G⋅34πR3ρ=38πGρR, showing that for fixed density the escape velocity is directly proportional to the radius. Therefore ve,Bve,A=RBRA=2RR=21, giving the ratio 1 : 2. The option 1 : 4 wrongly uses the square of the radius ratio. The option 1 : √2 incorrectly takes a square root, ignoring that mass grows as the cube of radius. The option 1 : 8 mistakenly applies the full cube. This extends the NCERT escape-velocity result to bodies of equal density. The relation ve=38πGρR is a useful diagnostic because it cleanly separates the two ways a planet can have a high escape velocity: by being made of denser material, or by being physically larger. For planet B, the radius doubles and the mass grows eightfold as R3, yet because escape velocity depends on the mass-to-radius combination M/R, the net scaling reduces to simple proportionality with radius. A plausibility check confirms that the larger planet, packing eight times the mass into twice the radius, demands a higher escape speed, so planet A's escape velocity being half that of B is consistent.
This hard difficulty physics question is from the chapter gravitation, covering the topic of escape velocity and planetary density. It appeared in the 2025 exam.
Looking for more practice? Explore all physics questions or browse gravitation questions on RankGuru.