Electrophilic Substitution In Haloarenes
Although chlorine withdraws electrons inductively, nitration of chlorobenzene yields mainly ortho and para products; how is this directing behaviour explained?
Select the correct option:
Solution
Chlorine donates a lone pair by resonance, enriching the ortho and para positions
Chlorine attached to a benzene ring exerts two opposing electronic effects. Through its high electronegativity it withdraws electron density inductively, deactivating the ring and slowing electrophilic substitution overall. However, chlorine also possesses lone pairs that it donates into the ring by resonance, and these resonance structures place extra negative charge specifically at the ortho and para positions. Because the electrophile seeks the most electron-rich sites, substitution occurs mainly ortho and para, even though the ring as a whole is deactivated. The uniform-density option is wrong because the resonance donation is selective, concentrating charge at ortho and para, not everywhere equally. The meta-directing option is incorrect because meta direction is typical of purely electron-withdrawing groups lacking donatable lone pairs, unlike chlorine. The steric option is wrong because both ortho and para products form; direction is electronic, not purely steric. The apparent paradox of a deactivating yet ortho-para directing group is resolved by recognising that the inductive withdrawal controls the overall rate, slowing every position, while the resonance donation controls the regioselectivity, sparing the ortho and para sites from the worst destabilisation in the intermediate. The para product usually dominates over ortho because the ortho position suffers additional steric and electronic strain near the bulky electronegative chlorine. This matches the NCERT explanation of halogens as deactivating yet ortho-para directing. Sanity check: resonance enriches ortho and para, so the electrophile lands there.
🔒 Solution Hidden from View
Submit your answer to unlock the detailed step-by-step solution.
About This Question
- Subject
- chemistry
- Chapter
- organic compounds containing halogens
- Topic
- electrophilic substitution in haloarenes
- Difficulty
- Medium
- Year
- 2025
Solution
Correct Answer:
Chlorine donates a lone pair by resonance, enriching the ortho and para positions
Chlorine attached to a benzene ring exerts two opposing electronic effects. Through its high electronegativity it withdraws electron density inductively, deactivating the ring and slowing electrophilic substitution overall. However, chlorine also possesses lone pairs that it donates into the ring by resonance, and these resonance structures place extra negative charge specifically at the ortho and para positions. Because the electrophile seeks the most electron-rich sites, substitution occurs mainly ortho and para, even though the ring as a whole is deactivated. The uniform-density option is wrong because the resonance donation is selective, concentrating charge at ortho and para, not everywhere equally. The meta-directing option is incorrect because meta direction is typical of purely electron-withdrawing groups lacking donatable lone pairs, unlike chlorine. The steric option is wrong because both ortho and para products form; direction is electronic, not purely steric. The apparent paradox of a deactivating yet ortho-para directing group is resolved by recognising that the inductive withdrawal controls the overall rate, slowing every position, while the resonance donation controls the regioselectivity, sparing the ortho and para sites from the worst destabilisation in the intermediate. The para product usually dominates over ortho because the ortho position suffers additional steric and electronic strain near the bulky electronegative chlorine. This matches the NCERT explanation of halogens as deactivating yet ortho-para directing. Sanity check: resonance enriches ortho and para, so the electrophile lands there.
This medium difficulty chemistry question is from the chapter organic compounds containing halogens, covering the topic of electrophilic substitution in haloarenes. It appeared in the 2025 exam.
Looking for more practice? Explore all chemistry questions or browse organic compounds containing halogens questions on RankGuru.