Detection Of Halogens
Halogens in an organic compound are not detected by directly adding silver nitrate to the compound but only after sodium fusion; what is the chief reason for this requirement?
Select the correct option:
Solution
Covalently bonded halogen must first be converted to free halide ions
In most organic compounds the halogen atom is bonded covalently to carbon and is therefore not available as a free halide ion in solution. Silver nitrate detects halogens by precipitating insoluble silver halides, but this requires the halogen to be present as ionic chloride, bromide, or iodide. Direct addition of silver nitrate to the organic compound fails because covalently bound halogen does not ionise and cannot form the precipitate. Sodium fusion solves this by reacting the compound with sodium metal, converting the covalent halogen into sodium halide (NaX), which is ionic and water soluble. The aqueous sodium fusion extract is then acidified with dilute nitric acid (to destroy cyanide or sulphide that would otherwise interfere) and treated with silver nitrate to give the characteristic precipitate. The claim about silver nitrate not dissolving in organic solvents misses the real point about covalent bonding. Raising temperature alone does not free the halide ion. Halogens do not simply evaporate away. This conversion of covalent halogen to ionic halide is the NCERT rationale. Plausibility check: only ionic halide can precipitate with silver ions, so fusion is essential.
🔒 Solution Hidden from View
Submit your answer to unlock the detailed step-by-step solution.
More detection of halogens Practice Questions
About This Question
- Subject
- chemistry
- Chapter
- purification and characterisation of organic compounds
- Topic
- detection of halogens
- Difficulty
- Medium
- Year
- 2025
Solution
Correct Answer:
Covalently bonded halogen must first be converted to free halide ions
In most organic compounds the halogen atom is bonded covalently to carbon and is therefore not available as a free halide ion in solution. Silver nitrate detects halogens by precipitating insoluble silver halides, but this requires the halogen to be present as ionic chloride, bromide, or iodide. Direct addition of silver nitrate to the organic compound fails because covalently bound halogen does not ionise and cannot form the precipitate. Sodium fusion solves this by reacting the compound with sodium metal, converting the covalent halogen into sodium halide (NaX), which is ionic and water soluble. The aqueous sodium fusion extract is then acidified with dilute nitric acid (to destroy cyanide or sulphide that would otherwise interfere) and treated with silver nitrate to give the characteristic precipitate. The claim about silver nitrate not dissolving in organic solvents misses the real point about covalent bonding. Raising temperature alone does not free the halide ion. Halogens do not simply evaporate away. This conversion of covalent halogen to ionic halide is the NCERT rationale. Plausibility check: only ionic halide can precipitate with silver ions, so fusion is essential.
This medium difficulty chemistry question is from the chapter purification and characterisation of organic compounds, covering the topic of detection of halogens. It appeared in the 2025 exam.
Looking for more practice? Explore all chemistry questions or browse purification and characterisation of organic compounds questions on RankGuru.