Closest Approach In Two-dimensional Relative Motion
Two ships start from the same instant: ship A is 100 m due east of ship B and sails north at 5 m/s, while ship B sails east at 5 m/s. What is the minimum separation distance between the two ships during their subsequent motion?
Select the correct option:
Solution
50√2 m
Minimum separation problems are most cleanly solved in the relative frame, where one ship is treated as stationary and the other moves with the relative velocity along a straight line; the closest approach is the perpendicular distance from the stationary ship to that line. Place ship B at the origin and ship A initially at (100,0). Ship A's velocity is (0,5) and ship B's is (5,0), so A's velocity relative to B is (0−5,5−0)=(−5,5) m/s. In B's frame, A starts at (100,0) and travels along the direction (−5,5), i.e. (−1,1) normalized. The closest approach is the perpendicular distance from the origin to the line through (100,0) with direction (−1,1). That line is x+y=100, and the distance from the origin is 12+12∣0+0−100∣=2100=502 m. The option 100 m is the initial separation, not the minimum. The option 50 m and 100√2 m arise from arithmetic mis-scaling of the perpendicular distance. This is the JEE Advanced relative-frame technique for closest approach. As a check, 502≈70.7 m is sensibly less than the starting 100 m, confirming the ships first draw nearer before separating.
🔒 Solution Hidden from View
Submit your answer to unlock the detailed step-by-step solution.
About This Question
- Subject
- physics
- Chapter
- kinematics
- Topic
- closest approach in two-dimensional relative motion
- Difficulty
- Hard
- Year
- 2025
Solution
Correct Answer:
50√2 m
Minimum separation problems are most cleanly solved in the relative frame, where one ship is treated as stationary and the other moves with the relative velocity along a straight line; the closest approach is the perpendicular distance from the stationary ship to that line. Place ship B at the origin and ship A initially at (100,0). Ship A's velocity is (0,5) and ship B's is (5,0), so A's velocity relative to B is (0−5,5−0)=(−5,5) m/s. In B's frame, A starts at (100,0) and travels along the direction (−5,5), i.e. (−1,1) normalized. The closest approach is the perpendicular distance from the origin to the line through (100,0) with direction (−1,1). That line is x+y=100, and the distance from the origin is 12+12∣0+0−100∣=2100=502 m. The option 100 m is the initial separation, not the minimum. The option 50 m and 100√2 m arise from arithmetic mis-scaling of the perpendicular distance. This is the JEE Advanced relative-frame technique for closest approach. As a check, 502≈70.7 m is sensibly less than the starting 100 m, confirming the ships first draw nearer before separating.
This hard difficulty physics question is from the chapter kinematics, covering the topic of closest approach in two-dimensional relative motion. It appeared in the 2025 exam.
Looking for more practice? Explore all physics questions or browse kinematics questions on RankGuru.