Circular Motion Of A Charged Particle
An electron and a proton enter the same uniform magnetic field perpendicularly with identical kinetic energies. Considering the radius of their circular paths, which particle traces the larger circle and by what governing factor?
Select the correct option:
Solution
Proton, because radius scales as m for equal kinetic energy
A charged particle moving perpendicular to a uniform field follows a circle whose radius comes from equating the magnetic force to the centripetal requirement: qvB=rmv2, giving r=qBmv. Expressing momentum through kinetic energy, mv=2mK, so r=qB2mK. For equal kinetic energy K and equal field B, and since the magnitudes of electron and proton charge are the same, the radius depends only on m. The proton is roughly 1836 times more massive than the electron, so it traces a substantially larger circle, with r∝m. The option claiming the electron traces the larger circle inverts the mass dependence. The option stating equal radii ignores that radius grows with momentum, not energy alone. The option claiming mass independence contradicts the derived m factor. This analysis underlies mass spectrometry, an NCERT application. A consistency check: heavier particles carry more momentum at the same energy, so a larger radius is physically expected. This square-root dependence on mass is precisely what allows a mass spectrometer to separate ions: feeding particles of equal energy into a uniform field spreads them onto arcs of differing radii according to their masses, so heavier isotopes land farther out on the detector. The same reasoning explains why, in fusion and particle-physics contexts, controlling the field strength tunes how tightly charged particles of a given energy are confined.
🔒 Solution Hidden from View
Submit your answer to unlock the detailed step-by-step solution.
About This Question
- Subject
- physics
- Chapter
- magnetic effects of current and magnetism
- Topic
- circular motion of a charged particle
- Difficulty
- Hard
- Year
- 2025
Solution
Correct Answer:
Proton, because radius scales as m for equal kinetic energy
A charged particle moving perpendicular to a uniform field follows a circle whose radius comes from equating the magnetic force to the centripetal requirement: qvB=rmv2, giving r=qBmv. Expressing momentum through kinetic energy, mv=2mK, so r=qB2mK. For equal kinetic energy K and equal field B, and since the magnitudes of electron and proton charge are the same, the radius depends only on m. The proton is roughly 1836 times more massive than the electron, so it traces a substantially larger circle, with r∝m. The option claiming the electron traces the larger circle inverts the mass dependence. The option stating equal radii ignores that radius grows with momentum, not energy alone. The option claiming mass independence contradicts the derived m factor. This analysis underlies mass spectrometry, an NCERT application. A consistency check: heavier particles carry more momentum at the same energy, so a larger radius is physically expected. This square-root dependence on mass is precisely what allows a mass spectrometer to separate ions: feeding particles of equal energy into a uniform field spreads them onto arcs of differing radii according to their masses, so heavier isotopes land farther out on the detector. The same reasoning explains why, in fusion and particle-physics contexts, controlling the field strength tunes how tightly charged particles of a given energy are confined.
This hard difficulty physics question is from the chapter magnetic effects of current and magnetism, covering the topic of circular motion of a charged particle. It appeared in the 2025 exam.
Looking for more practice? Explore all physics questions or browse magnetic effects of current and magnetism questions on RankGuru.