Carnot Engine Energy Accounting
A Carnot engine working between 500 K and 300 K absorbs 1000 J of heat from the hot reservoir in each cycle. How much heat does it reject to the cold reservoir per cycle?
Select the correct option:
Solution
600 J
For a reversible Carnot cycle the heats exchanged with the two reservoirs are tied to their absolute temperatures by QHQC=THTC, a consequence of the entropy change being zero over the reversible cycle. Solving for the rejected heat gives QC=QHTHTC=1000×500300=600 J. The value 400 J is actually the net work W=QH−QC=1000−600, not the rejected heat. The value 500 J would require equal temperatures or a wrong ratio. The value 300 J mistakes the cold temperature in kelvin for the heat in joules. We can cross-check using efficiency: η=1−TC/TH=1−300/500=0.4, so the work is 0.4×1000=400 J and the rejected heat is 1000−400=600 J, matching exactly. This entropy balance, expressed as QH/TH=QC/TC, states that the entropy gained by the gas from the hot reservoir is exactly returned to the cold reservoir, so the total entropy change over the reversible cycle is zero. Any real irreversible engine between the same reservoirs would reject more than 600 J and thus do less work, increasing total entropy as the Second Law demands.
🔒 Solution Hidden from View
Submit your answer to unlock the detailed step-by-step solution.
About This Question
- Subject
- physics
- Chapter
- thermodynamics
- Topic
- carnot engine energy accounting
- Difficulty
- Hard
- Year
- 2025
Solution
Correct Answer:
600 J
For a reversible Carnot cycle the heats exchanged with the two reservoirs are tied to their absolute temperatures by QHQC=THTC, a consequence of the entropy change being zero over the reversible cycle. Solving for the rejected heat gives QC=QHTHTC=1000×500300=600 J. The value 400 J is actually the net work W=QH−QC=1000−600, not the rejected heat. The value 500 J would require equal temperatures or a wrong ratio. The value 300 J mistakes the cold temperature in kelvin for the heat in joules. We can cross-check using efficiency: η=1−TC/TH=1−300/500=0.4, so the work is 0.4×1000=400 J and the rejected heat is 1000−400=600 J, matching exactly. This entropy balance, expressed as QH/TH=QC/TC, states that the entropy gained by the gas from the hot reservoir is exactly returned to the cold reservoir, so the total entropy change over the reversible cycle is zero. Any real irreversible engine between the same reservoirs would reject more than 600 J and thus do less work, increasing total entropy as the Second Law demands.
This hard difficulty physics question is from the chapter thermodynamics, covering the topic of carnot engine energy accounting. It appeared in the 2025 exam.
Looking for more practice? Explore all physics questions or browse thermodynamics questions on RankGuru.